top of page

Best Alternatives to Bed Bath & Beyond: Where to Shop Now for Bedding, Bath, Kitchen, and More

9 hours ago
6 min read

No single store is a perfect alternative to Bed Bath & Beyond. But based on a Numerator survey of 500 former BB&B customers, Target, Amazon, Walmart, and HomeGoods cover the most ground — across bedding, bath, kitchen, décor, and storage. Here's the full breakdown.


What Shoppers Lost When Bed Bath & Beyond Closed


Bed Bath & Beyond wasn't just a home goods store — it was a particular kind of shopping experience. Browsable aisles. Stacked coupons. A reliable price point that sat between discount and mid-range. That combination is genuinely hard to replicate in one place.


When Numerator surveyed 500 former BB&B customers after the closures, the results were telling. The top things shoppers said they'd miss: product selection (59%), deals (56%), prices (31%), and store locations (28%). Six in ten described themselves as upset about the closures.


What's often overlooked is that BB&B filled a specific retail gap — not luxury, not dollar-store, not warehouse bulk. It was a middle-ground store for everyday home needs, according to Wikipedia's overview of Bed Bath & Beyond's retail history, and that middle ground is now split across several retailers.


Once counted among the Fortune 500 companies, the chain filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in April 2023 and closed all remaining stores by July 30 of that year.


Is Bed Bath & Beyond Coming Back?


Short answer: the physical stores are not coming back.


Overstock acquired the Bed Bath & Beyond brand name and relaunched bedbathandbeyond.com as an online-only home goods store.


As reported by CNN Business, the website launched on August 1, 2023, merging Overstock's existing inventory with product categories familiar to BB&B shoppers — though physical locations remain off the table.


So if you're searching for a bed bath and beyond replacement specifically for in-store shopping, the relaunched website won't solve that. The alternatives below are what most displaced shoppers are actually using.



Best Alternatives to Bed Bath & Beyond by Product Category


This is where the data gets useful. Rather than guessing which stores come closest overall, the Numerator survey broke consumer preferences down by category. The results show that no single store dominates every category equally — which is why most former BB&B shoppers now split their purchases across two or three retailers.


Target, Amazon, and Walmart consistently pull ahead across categories because each invests heavily in price, convenience, and loyalty incentives simultaneously — covering nearly every gap BB&B left behind.


Bedding


Store

% of Shoppers Choosing It

Target

54%

Amazon

52%

Walmart

37%

HomeGoods

30%


Target and Amazon run nearly neck and neck for bedding. In practice, shoppers who want to see and feel bedding before buying tend to lean toward Target or HomeGoods. Those comfortable buying online often go straight to Amazon for the range and price competition.


Bath Products


Store

% of Shoppers Choosing It

Target

61%

Amazon

52%

Walmart

49%

HomeGoods

32%


Bath is where Target pulls furthest ahead. It's one of the few categories where a single store breaks 60%. Walmart closes the gap here more than in any other category — useful to know if you're combining a grocery run with a home goods top-up.


Kitchen & Dining


Store

% of Shoppers Choosing It

Target

56%

Amazon

55%

Walmart

49%

HomeGoods

33%


Kitchen and dining is tightly contested between Target and Amazon. Walmart isn't far behind either. Interestingly, HomeGoods holds its own here — the off-price model works well for cookware and tableware, where brand loyalty tends to be lower.


Small Appliances


Store

% of Shoppers Choosing It

Target

64%

Walmart

62%

Amazon

61%

Macy's

12%


Small appliances is the one category where Macy's makes the list at all. It's a distant fourth, but worth noting if you're looking for a specific brand or model at a department store. The top three — Target, Walmart, Amazon — are almost indistinguishable in preference here.


Home Décor


Store

% of Shoppers Choosing It

Target

52%

Amazon

48%

HomeGoods

44%

Walmart

31%


HomeGoods comes closest to matching the big two in décor. That tracks — the off-price, treasure-hunt format suits decorative items well. Walmart drops off noticeably here compared to its performance in other categories.


Storage & Organization


Store

% of Shoppers Choosing It

Target

58%

Amazon

58%

Walmart

57%

HomeGoods

26%


Nearly identical across the top three. If you're replacing BB&B specifically for storage and organization products, you're unlikely to go wrong with any of them. HomeGoods is less reliable in this category.


How the Top Alternatives Compare at a Glance


This table summarizes how the most-used alternatives stack up across the factors that matter most to former BB&B shoppers — price, availability, and savings programs.


Store

Best For

Price vs. BB&B

In-Store

Online

Savings Program

Target

All categories

Similar

✅

✅

Target Circle

Amazon

All categories, online

Varies

❌

✅

Prime

Walmart

Budget essentials

Lower

✅

✅

Walmart+

HomeGoods

Décor, bedding

Similar–Lower

✅

Limited

None

Macy's

Small appliances

Higher

✅

✅

Star Rewards

Costco / BJ's

Bulk household goods

Lower (membership req.)

✅

✅

Membership perks

BB&B.com (Beyond Inc.)

Online home goods

Varies

❌

✅

Club O


One thing worth noting: BB&B was fundamentally an in-store experience. Browsing the aisles, handling products, using a paper coupon at checkout — that's what most loyal customers describe missing. Amazon and BB&B.com can't replicate that. Target and HomeGoods come closest for shoppers who want a physical store.


Also Read: What Are Five Marketing Strategies That Retailers Spend Half of Their Annual Budget On


Which Alternative Is Right for Your Situation


For Dorm and College Shopping


Budget-first


Target and Walmart both run dedicated college sections with competitive pricing on bedding, storage, and kitchen basics. Target's college shop in particular is one of the more organized options available in-store and online.


Style-forward


West Elm offers a dorm-specific section with a shoppable checklist — similar to what BB&B used to provide. Urban Outfitters Home is worth a look for smaller, design-led pieces. Both skew higher in price than BB&B did.


For Budget-First Shoppers


In-store


Walmart is the most straightforward like-for-like on price. HomeGoods can deliver unexpected value, especially on décor and bedding, though the inventory is inconsistent by design.


Online


Amazon's price competition and Walmart.com's everyday low pricing make both solid choices. In practice, shoppers who combine Subscribe & Save on consumables with individual product searches tend to come out ahead.


For Bulk Buyers


Membership warehouse stores


Costco and BJ's Wholesale Club are the clearest alternatives for shoppers who bought household essentials in volume at BB&B. Both require annual memberships, but the per-unit savings on towels, bedding basics, and cleaning supplies are generally meaningful for households that use a lot of them.


For Online-Only Shoppers


Widest selection


Amazon. Not a close contest on breadth of inventory or speed of delivery.


Closest to original BB&B experience online


BB&B.com under Beyond Inc. is worth checking — it carries home goods across the same categories the original store did, and the brand name still carries recognition. That said, it functions as a standard e-commerce site, not a direct continuation of what BB&B was.


What Replaced Bed Bath & Beyond's Coupons?


This is the part that still frustrates a lot of former customers. BB&B's coupon model — 20% off a single item, no expiry date, often stackable — was genuinely unusual in retail. No current retailer has replicated it directly.


What's available now is different in kind, not just degree:


  • Target Circle — weekly percentage-off deals, cashback on purchases, category-specific discounts

  • Walmart+ — free delivery, member pricing on select items, Paramount+ streaming included

  • Amazon Prime — Subscribe & Save discounts, exclusive Prime pricing, early deal access

  • Costco / BJ's membership — bulk pricing built in, no coupon hunting required


None of these feel like a direct swap for the BB&B coupon. In practice, most former BB&B shoppers find that Target Circle comes closest for regular home goods discounts — but it's a loyalty program, not a blanket discount you can apply whenever you want.



Frequently Asked Questions


Which store is the closest overall alternative to Bed Bath & Beyond?


Based on consumer survey data, Target ranks first across every major BB&B product category — bedding, bath, kitchen, décor, small appliances, and storage. It's the single closest replacement, though most shoppers use it alongside Amazon or Walmart.


Is Bed Bath & Beyond coming back?


Physical stores are permanently closed. The brand was acquired by Overstock (now Beyond Inc.), which relaunched bedbathandbeyond.com as an online-only store. It sells home goods across similar categories but has no physical locations.


Does any store still honor Bed Bath & Beyond coupons?


No. After BB&B's closure, sister brands including The Container Store and Kirkland's Home stopped honoring the coupons. No current retailer has adopted a comparable blanket coupon program.


Is the Bed Bath & Beyond website still active?


Yes. Bedbathandbeyond.com was relaunched under Overstock's ownership (now Beyond Inc.) as an online home goods store. It is a functioning e-commerce site, though it operates differently from the original retail chain.


What is the best in-store alternative to Bed Bath & Beyond?


For in-store shopping, Target and HomeGoods are the most commonly cited replacements. Target covers the widest category range; HomeGoods tends to offer better off-price finds on décor and bedding specifically.


Conclusion


No single store replaces Bed Bath & Beyond completely. Target comes closest across categories. Amazon leads online. Walmart wins on price. For in-store browsing, HomeGoods fills part of the gap. Most former BB&B shoppers now split purchases across two or three of these depending on what they need.


 
 
bottom of page